SBI Fungicides Meeting 2005
International FRAC SBI Working Group Minutes


Summaries and recommendations from the 2005 meeting of the Fungicide Resistance Action Committee (FRAC)

Sterol Biosynthesis Inhibitor (SBI) Working Group

Hosting company: BASF AG, Crop Protection Division

Venue of the meeting: DuPont de Nemours, Bad Homburg, Germany

Date: 12th October 2005


Contents

ANNUAL MEETING 2005
Key Points from meeting
CEREAL DISEASES
NON-CEREAL DISEASES
Fenhexamid

Key Points from meeting

The 2005 meeting reviewed the most recent monitoring work undertaken directly by Agrochemical Companies or sponsored by them with academic institutions. Based on a review of these data, following statements have been prepared which summarise the most up-to-date knowledge available regarding resistance to SBI fungicides.

Generally in 2005 a stable situation was found with DMI’s and amines.
The guidelines for adherence to recommended use rates were emphasised for cereals.

Wheat

Powdery mildew: stable situation (DMI and amines)
Septoria tritici: After the slight increase in the frequency of less sensitive isolates from 2002 to 2004, the situation has generally stabilised in 2005.
Yellow and brown rust: field performance of DMI’s remains good.

Barley

Rhynchosporium: : Generally stable situation.
Net blotch: DMI performance unchanged.
Powdery mildew: stable situation (DMI and amines).

Vines

Powdery mildew: performance unchanged (DMI and amines).

Apples

Scab: DMI performance unchanged.
Powdery mildew: DMI performance unchanged.

Fenhexamid (hydroxyanilide) – new SBI class

No change in sensitivity and performance against Botrytis since introduction in 1998.

CEREAL DISEASES

BARLEY
 
Barley Powdery Mildew
(Blumeria graminis f.sp. hordei / Erysiphe graminis f.sp. hordei)
In 2005, disease pressure was generally moderate.

DMIs
Sensitivity data were reported for prothioconazole. The sensitivity of the populations stayed in the range of variation observed in the past seven years.

Amines
Sensitivity data were reported for fenpropidine and spiroxamine . The sensitivity of the populations stayed in the range observed in the previous years. Morpholine products performed well with no farmer complaints.

Scald (Rhynchosporium secalis)
Normal disease infection levels in 2005.Generally stable situation. Sensitivity monitoring data were presented for epoxiconazole (2005), prothioconazole (2004) and tebuconazole (2004): the sensitivity of the populations stayed in the range observed in the previous years.

Net Blotch (Pyrenophora teres /Drechslera teres)
Disease incidence was medium to high in 2005. Sensitivity monitoring data were presented for prothioconazole (2004) .The sensitivity of the populations stayed in the range observed in the previous years. Field disease control was good with no problems reported.


WHEAT
 
Wheat powdery mildew
(Blumeria graminis f.sp. tritici / Erysiphe graminis f.sp. tritici)

Disease pressure was generally medium to high across Europe.

DMIs: Sensitivity data were presented for tebuconazole and prothioconazole, confirming that the situation was generally stable remaining in the range of variability seen over the past 10 years. No complaints from field use. The performance of DMI based products was as expected.

Animes: Sensitivity data were presented for fenpropidin, fenpropimorph and spiroxamine, confirming that the situation was generally stable remaining in the range of variability seen over the past 10 years. Field performance of amine based products was good with no complaints.

Wheat Leaf Spot (Mycosphaerella graminicola / Septoria tritici)

Disease pressure was heterogeneous in Europe in 2005, from moderate to high (North of France). DMI’s field performance was generally good . After the slight increase in the frequency of less sensitive isolates from 2002 to 2004, the situation has generally stabilised in 2005.

Wheat Eyespot (Tapesia spp. / Pseudocercosporella herpotrichoides)

Sensitivity data (W and R types) have been presented for prothioconazole. Stable situation has been observed for the last two years.

Rusts (Puccinia recondita and P. striiformis)

Brown rust disease pressure was high in Belgium and UK, low to moderate in the rest of Europe. Yellow rust incidence was high in UK. Performance of DMI’s on both brown and yellow rust has been maintained. No sensitivity data were presented.

NON-CEREAL DISEASES
 
  Grape Powdery Mildew (Uncinula necator)

Disease pressure was normal to high in 2005. Performance of DMIs and “amines” was as expected. Spiroxamine monitoring data have been reported for 2004. The sensitivity of the populations stayed in the range observed in the previous years.

Recommendations:

DMI´s should only be used as preventative and not in a curative manner. “Amines” should preferably be used as preventative and not in a curative manner.

The existing strategy for effective disease control and resistance management continues to be successful and the use recommendation is a maximum of 4 applications per season, before symptoms occur. The strategy includes the use of mixtures or alternation with non-cross resistant fungicides.

To ensure that SBI's can remain as the effective basis for Uncinula control in vines, the use of the full-recommended rate (either alone or in mixture), recommended timing, application volume and accurate treatment of each row should be adhered to.

Apple Scab (Venturia inaequalis)

The performance of DMI’s was good on this disease in 2005 when compounds were used according to the manufacturers’ and FRAC recommendations. Sensitivity data (2005) indicated that no new sensitivity classes have appeared since 1993, although the most sensitive class have disappeared as shown from 2003 compared to 1993.

Recommendations:

DMI fungicides, which are labelled for scab control, are not recommended for season long use and a maximum of 4 DMI sprays either alone or in mixture is recommended.

Where repeated fungicide applications are required, DMI's should be used in mixtures or (block) alternations with a non-cross resistant fungicide. Application of recommended label rates is important.

Preventative applications should always be the first choice with DMI’s. Curative applications are only recommended when accurate disease warning systems are available.

Apple Powdery Mildew (Podosphaera leucotricha)

No complaints were received on the performance of DMI’s when compounds were used according to the manufacturers’ recommendation and FRAC recommendations.
For recommendations see General Recommendations.

Soybean rust (Phakopsora pachyrhizi)
See the FRAC-Brazil website for information (frac@frac-brasil.org.br) when available.
Monitoring methods for baseline establishment and follow-up are being developed.

Banana Sigatoka (Mycosphaerella fijiensis)

The conclusions and guidelines of the Feb. 2004 meeting of the FRAC Banana Working Group are available on the FRAC Website.

Apple Powdery Mildew (Podosphaera leucotricha)

No complaints were received on the performance of DMI’s when compounds were used according to the manufacturers’ recommendation and FRAC recommendations.
For recommendations see General Recommendations.

Soybean rust (Phakopsora pachyrhizi)

See the FRAC-Brazil website for information (frac@frac-brasil.org.br) when available.
Monitoring methods for baseline establishment and follow-up are being developed.

Banana Sigatoka (Mycosphaerella fijiensis)

The conclusions and guidelines of the Feb. 2004 meeting of the FRAC Banana Working Group are available on the FRAC Website.

Fenhexamid (Hydroxyanilides)

Considered a SBI with activity on Botrytis cinerea, which is a high-risk disease. New biochemical mode of action and no cross-resistance with other botryticides. Targets: 4,4-dimethylfecosterol and 4,alpha-dimethylfecosterol in Sterol Biosynthesis pathway (C4 demethylation). Regarded as an inhibitor of C3-ketoreductase.
2005 monitoring studies are in progress

Recommendations for use of Fenhexamid: use fenhexamid only protectively.

Straight product:

Spray schedules with a maximum of 3 treatments per season: max. 1 application with fenhexamid
Spray schedules with 4-5 treatments/season: max. 2 applications with fenhexamid
Spray schedules with 6 and more treatments: at the maximum one third of all Botryticide-applications

Mixtures:

Both partners - if applied alone at the dose used in the mixture - must have sufficient activity against Botrytis. Not more than 50% of all Botryticide-treatments should be made with fenhexamid-containing mixtures.

 
 
 
Contact



J.-M. Gouot
Chairman

Bayer CropScience SA
La Dargoire Research Center
14/20 Rue Pierre Baizet
69263 Lyon Cedex 09,
France
Tel: +33 47 28 52 391
Fax: +33 47 28 52 871
Email: J.-M. Gouot

Site

Disclaimer
Impressum
SBI Archive

Copyright FRAC 2005